The European UnionThe European Union A New Economic Rival or The Ultimate Counterweight? presented to The Raleigh Tavern Philosophical Society www.raleightavern.org
raleightavern.org/eu.pdf
DOWNLOAD
| Find Similar
advertisement
Text Previews (text result may be not accurate) The Ultimate Counterweight?
.............3
..............................................................................8
....13
...........................................................................................15
The Ultimate Counterweight
The European Union has just recently admitted ten new nations, mostly from the Eastern
war against the forces of disconnectedness, the U.S. ends up dividing the West and the Trans-
economic sanctions on Syria (5/10/04) for failing to cooperate on the war on terrorism, the
European Union sent a trade delegation to Syria as an obvious affront to the U.S. (5/13/04).
The Pew Research Center released a global attitudes pollŽ (March 16, 2004) which
measured the European Unions rift with the U.S. war in Iraq and it revealed an intensified
discontentŽ with America and its policies. It also showed a growing percentage of Europeans
want foreign policy and security arrangement independent from the U.S. ƒ and there was a
considerable support for the European Union to become as powerful as the U.S. (emphasis
In your opinion would it be a good thing or a bad thing if the European Union becomes
as powerful as the U.S.?Ž
Good
France909+81
Germany7022+48
Russia6712+55
Great Britain5039+11
U.S.A.6921+48
France1678-62
Germany2470-46
Russia1453-39
U.S.A.4246
France882
Germany884
Russia947
ƒdid (survey country) make the right decision or wrong decision to not use military
Right
France8811
Germany8611
Russia8310
France3561
Germany2965
Russia3548
France21753:1
Germany36632:1
Russia24562:1
The Cultural Divide: A Matter of Perception
Which is more important for government today: to guarantee no one is ever in need or
to provide freedom for individuals to pursue their goals (N.O.R.C., Chicago):
For
U.S.2560
France5535
Germany6040
Great Britain6025
Italy6520
U.S./ŽAmericanŽ80
U.K./ŽBritonŽ50-30
Fr./ŽFrenchŽ38-42
Ger./ŽGermanŽ20-60
How important would you say religion is in your own life.Ž (N.O.R.C.)
U.S.61
France10
Germany20
Italy25
Great Britain30
distinctive value system and unusual politics.Ž The Economist (Nov:03) cited the following
1.)
U.S. is among the most religious countries in the world.
2.)
Has the highest propensity for its citizens to join voluntary organizations.
3.)
Has one of the most highly decentralized political systems with more elective
offices than any other nation.
4.)
Never had any of the pre-conditions for either feudalism or aristocracy.
5.)
what we are fighting for in this current war,Ž Nat. Review).
8.)
4/13). One can see the angst in some European leaders when they say that America is both a
The new American position (via The Bush DoctrineŽ) is more interventionist, justified
by self-defense and human rights. In the recent work by Daalder and Lindsay (America
(1)
The U.S. today champions a new pro-active doctrine of (a) preemption and (b)
(4)
The Europeans see a world of lawŽ whereby the international order can constrain
the U.S. autonomy and power; however, the Bush Administration sees a different
service, and his immediate ancestors were Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe who changed
their family name to KerryŽ and religion to Catholicism after arriving in the U.S. (see the new
French and German respondents say they have less confidence that the U.S. wants to promote
democracy all around the world. Only 1 in 5 Americans believes this (i.e., 80% of Americans
support the notion of Americans exceptional status in world history; see Kerrys French
Lessons,Ž The Hill, 3/24/04). Kerrys embracing of Europes criticisms, while attempting to turn
Kerry refused to name the European leaders he had allegedly talked to when he shared their
criticisms, his campaign has lost momentum despite his primary election successes.
What is becoming increasingly clear to the American public is, in Ken Timmermans
See Clif Fox, A Constitution for Europe?Ž :Žƒ for DeGaulle, an important function of the European Community
The Trans-Atlantic Problem Today
Including Kerrys espousal of European criticisms, one might pose the question about our
with U.S. policy toward Iraq by leading an international opposition against it. Additionally,
Americans resent France in particular for their lack of solidarity and the French resent the U.S.
both sides to cope with differences.Ž
Some of the underlying dynamics that will have to be kept in mind for the future found in
After the 9/11 tragedy and compassion faded, Europe quickly reestablished its
distance from an America entirely absorbed in the war against terrorism.
(2)
(3)
The U.S. will (perhaps reluctantly) be required to be more attentive to the
There has been a simple recurrence of an age-old left wing anti-
imperialism (particularly in France) refurbished with the fantasies and
resentments provoked by the new American-driven globalization seen as a
steamroller and by the assertion of and speed of American military power
in the world.Ž (see America As Empire: Global Leader or Rogue Power?,
(2)
The European Union has exclusive jurisdiction to defend the economic
and trade interests of its member states and makes good use of it against
elites of the 18
democratic capitalist power juxtaposed to classic collectivist/Socialist
countermodels which were nationalistic, anti-capitalist and anticolonialist.
This is called historical anti-Americanism and it differs from the more
(8)
Another cause for the rift is the intellectual consequences from the
Enlightenment
the British Enlightenment which promoted classical liberalism and the
French Enlightenment which promoted a more secular collectivist doctrine
of progress. The Enlightenment leaders believed in reason and science as
the privileged means of making sense of the world and subordinated
religion and spiritual aspects. What has lasted through the last three
reason, nature, and man were synthesized into a world viewŽ ƒ a celebration of reason, the power by which man
hand, the French Enlightenment emphasized the rationalism of elites
contemporary (post modern) version of the Enlightenment, especially the
French (Continental) Enlightenment which thinks they will create a global
and universal civilization both abroad and at home in the name of
progress.Ž One can see why the United Nations is preferred over a
unilateral U.S. if your intellectual traditions trace from the French
Enlightenment. (Kurth also criticizes Bushs neoconservatives as too
secular in their attacks emanating from post-modernists and for advancing
a kind of America Empire on the world.)
(9)
Speaking of the British Enlightenment, Great Britain has not been
prominently mentioned in this discussion about the Atlantic divide.Ž
They have backed the U.S. position in Iraq even under great duress; their
cultural numbers in the polls do not reflect an exact parallel to their
continental brothers, and they relish keeping the Anglo-American alliance
solid and steady. One historian mused that the British understand the
that the international system is most stable as in a Pax Americana when
from emerging. How that theory plays out with the European Union as the
counterweight to U.S. diplomacy remains to be seen.
America believes that it will, for the foreseeable future, shape the rules of world
order, not Europe. Europe fears American dominance and insists on strategic
restraint that helps explain why one poll in France showed that over 40% of the
French wanted the U.S. to lose the war in Iraq. Europe is not in polite
disagreement with the U.S. any longer and the Atlantic security bond is at a
crossroads. It portends a broader clash among geopolitical world views in the 21
The recent addition of ten nations to membership in the European Union is a good time
an affinity with the new former Warsaw Pact European Union membersƒ than with our old
European friends.Ž In a final thought, Windham then references Tom Friedman who has
suggested that we may very well be witnessing the beginning of the end of The WestŽ as we
have known it. Another, more common, expression might be with friends like this, who needs
enemies.Ž
Daalder & Lindsay. America Unbound. Brookings, 2003.
Europes Big Gamble.Ž National Geographic. May, 2004.
Kennedy, Paul. The Rise & Fall of the Great Powers. Vintage, 1987.
A Reminder to France
died fighting for France but are buried and honored here in the U.S.
Meuse-Argonne15,200
Normandy10,944
St. Mihiel4,437
Aisne-Marne3,349
Suresnes998
Somme2,177
Epinal5,679
Brittany4,908
Rhone Dragungnan1,155
Oise-Aisne6,253
Lorraine10,933
The Contradistinction
Bradley Lecture(Washington)Publication Date: March 1, 2004
I want to speak this evening about what may seem a rather dramatic subject--the end of
Europe, by which I don't mean its disappearance from the map, but a fundamental
In order to illustrate my argument, I want to take you back very far in time. In fact, I
,
in Chapter 52, Part 2, he describes what might have happened if the Muslim that had
least a kind of disruptive influence on American power? The world is not really unipolar
I want to add a little footnote to this story. If you look closely at man-hour statistics-
comparing the productivity of, say, a Frenchman in a single hour with that of his
There is only one way out for this continent, and that is immigration. There is an obvious